The Best Butter Chicken in New York
New York – The Big Apple, the city that never sleeps, a city filled with diversity and dynamism, is considered the financial capital of the USA it is one of the most populous cities in the world. Making it the perfect melting pot of cultures, cuisines, art, and more.
Situated on the shores of the Atlantic it’s one of the most expensive cities to live in the world. With the largest Indian population in the United States, with close to 700,000 Indians living and working here. It is bound to have a treasure trove of Indian dining options, so lets take a dive through this complex and beautiful cityscape and discover the Best Butter Chicken New York has to offer
7 Best Butter Chicken in New York
1. Bengal Tiger

Location: 58W 56th Street, 2nd Floor, New York, NY 10019
Website: https://www.bengaltigerindianfood.com/
About the restaurant: The restuarant is located close to central park and is on the first floor,though it is a small space and a tight fit, the space has been used well giving the restaurant a homely and cozy vibe. Known for its wide array of veg and nonveg food its been a hot spot for families and large groups.
Bengal Tiger‘s Butter Chicken: A traditional tandoori marinade is used with a blend of spices mixed with thick greek yogurt, boneless chunks of chicken, cooked in a clay oven, accompanied with a creamy sweet and buttery tomato sauce. Definitely one of the best butter chicken in New York.
Cost: The murgh makhani as it is fondly called is costs $18 per serving, although you may be interested in trying one of their fixed three-course dinner menu costing $25. It is absolutely worth every penny considering the quality of food you receive.
2. Mughlai Indian Cuisine

Location: 255 West 55th Street, New York, NY 10019, Between 8th Avenue and Broadway
Website: https://mughlaicuisineny.com/
About the restaurant: Located in the heart of Manhattan, hop skip and a jump away from times square this dainty little restaurant has a homely and comforting vibe, with red brick walls, traditional food, and prompt service. They currently operate 3 locations across the city.
Mughlai‘s Butter Chicken: A mildly spiced butter chicken a favorite amongst expats and locals alike, a crowpleaser and a hearty serving size, and superfast deliver/service make it one of the competitors for the title of best butter chicken in New York.
Cost: $13.95 make it ideal for those days when you’re in a rush or back from a tiring day at the office, a quick simple and satisfying meal, pair it with their basmati rice.
3. Veeray Da Dhaba

Location: 222 1st Ave, New York, NY 10009 (between 13th & 14th Street)
Website: https://www.veeraydadhaba.com/menu
About the restaurant: Located in the lower part of Manhattan Island this lush and cozy restaurant is located amidst a treasure trove of some of the best restaurants New York has to offer. Chef Binder Saini heads the kitchen, considered one of the rising stars in contemporary Indian cuisine.
Veeray Da Dhaba‘s Butter Chicken: focuses on procuring the freshest ingredients from local sources seasonally. Boneless chicken tenders are marinated and cooked in a tandoor before being finished off with copious amounts of butter and a sweet and piquant tomato sauce.
Cost: $17 makes it affordable, but the overall dining experience and the showcase of local produce are what definitely make it worthwhile, and puts it on our list of best butter chicken in New York.
4. Sathi

Location: 216 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10003
Website: https://www.sathinewyork.com/
About the restaurant: A cozy restaurant offering curb-side dining options, known for its traditional take on food and its wide array of vegetarian and nonvegetarian delicacies.
Sathi‘s Butter Chicken: A creamy delicious sauce prepared from pureed nuts and blended with a sweet and tangy tomato sauce is topped with tandoor cooked chicken tikka with a nice spicy and deep after taste.
Cost: $15.95 makes it an idea for the potion size and overall ambiance is what sets it apart, don’t forget the exceptional taste. Making a hit on our list of best butter chicken in New York.
5. Pippali

Location: 129 E 27th St, New York, NY 10016
Website: https://www.pippalinyc.com/
About the restaurant: A upscale restaurant offering traditional and contemporary Indian cuisine, with a fully stocked bar and a warm and welcoming ambiance. A stone’s throw away from Madison Square Park.
Pipali‘s Butter Chicken: has a strong fenugreek flavor which is complemented by its thick and creamy makhani sauce prepared from sweet ripe tomatoes and a but puree. Shredded chicken is added to complete the dish. Pair it with a butter garlic naan as highly recommended by most patrons.
Cost: $19 is very affordable and worth your money considering the overall dining experience. Definitely a star performer on our list of best butter chicken in New York.
6. Bhatti Indian Grill

Location: 100 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016
Website: https://www.bhattinyc.com/
About the restaurant: Pronounced (Bhu-tea) it refers to the traditional wood fire grill in Indian cuisine, Bhatti is an authentic North Indian restaurant located in the heart of New York City, known for their delectable collection of kebabs and curries. The restaurant is located on a corner offering curb side dining, and well designed interiors. Chef Gaurav Anand of Awadh and Moti Mahal Delux has been the key driving force in the renovation of the restaurant in the wake of its 10th anniversary, designing a special menu for the event this year.
Bhatti‘s Butter Chicken: is grilled on open coals contrary to the tandoori cooking technique giving it a deeper smokier taste. It is then combined with a spicy tomato sauce flavoured with green chilies and a nut puree making it the perfect companion for that naan or basmati pulav.
Cost: Fondly called the Dilli Ka Butter Chicken is priced at $18.95 making it slightly expensive on our list but worth every morsel once you sink your teeth into that bowl full of goodness. Definitely one of the best butter chicken New York has to offer.
7. Moti Mahal Delux

Location: 1149 1st Ave 63rd Street, New York City, NY 10065-7779
Website: https://www.motimahaldelux.us/menu
About the restaurant: Located close to the Queensboro Bridge, its the first location of this iconic brand that began in Delhi and h=now has found its way across to many parts of the world. This restaurant is particularly known for popularizing the butter chicken with their signature recipe. It is a cozy and welcoming establishment with brilliant food and service.
Plush comfortable interiors paired with warm lighting give this restaurant an upscale and borugeios vibe.
Moti Mahal‘s Butter Chicken: Their signature sauce is a made of secret blend of spices passed down form the streets of Delhi, blended with creamy sweet and tangy tomatoes and topped with a nut puree, cream and loads of butter, making it the best butter chicken not only in new york but also the world.
Cost: $18.95 brings it in par with bhatti’s butter chicken but the sheer heritage and the tradtrional recipes and techniques used definitely sets it apart from the rest of the restaurants in New York.
Sign Up Today
Sign up to our newsletter and get the latest info.